The term "remix" has come to identify the phenomenon whereby a body of knowledge is understood through technology that rearranges and re-contextualizes it "in order to construct an original narrative," as would any multimedia emboldened web-based version of a museum object. Adopting such tools undoubtedly re-emphasizes the role of collections for public use and interest, while making their ability to inspire learning more participatory (Fisher 2007). Perhaps the most exciting innovation regarding the creation of surrogate virtual objects, and exhibitions to contextualize them within, is 3D imaging and modeling. Jim Forrest, Web Creative Director of the Peabody Essex Museum (PEM) in Salem, Massachusetts, sees the three-dimensional as the "next big phase" of web-development for online museum resources. His own recent projects include work on the virtual exhibition Joseph Cornell; Navigating the imagination (2007), which allows for interactive play and study with some of the artist's shadow boxes in simulated three-dimensions through the use of Flash animation and video, specifically Macromedia Flash Player 8.
One choice within this ongoing exhibit is to visit Cornell's "Little Dream Gum Machine," where the viewer can drag and drop a virtual penny into a slot to activate it. The penny cascades down the machine's revealed innards activating a link to other 2D digital versions of shadow boxes. this interactive play allows you to navigate through the collection and learn by seeing. Online web pages also serve adults and young learners at onsite computer kiosks like PEM's Art and Nature Center. Instruction on how to fold paper animals is among the hands on activities offered through Flash video in the Origami Now Folding Station 2007 web page for the exhibit Origami Now! (2007). Viewers learn by seeing and doing.
In addition to the digital images of origami works of art in Origami Now! , the computer-based interactive experience of this exhibit puts art in the context of not only something that is made by the artist, but something that you can make. Children and adults are enabled to learn what one can in the museum seemingly independent of educators, and this too may lend itself to unique experiences with objects and the hows and whys of their creation. The code of behavior required wthat barred the visitor from fully exploring the intricacies and the suggestive play of the real objects of Joseph Cornell's shadow boxes in the PEM exhibition are abandoned through the interactive play and study provided by these offerings in 3D animation and video. 3D virtual experiences with these objects are experientially more real than the more conventional single, frontal digital stills of objects contained in a digital collections database or the real object itself maintained within glass vitrines and motion detecting security fields whih put them out of reach of the visitor.
A collections database comprised totally of 3D images is for the time being unrealized at any museum, but there have been some, like PEM, that have taken the lead in creating examples of objects and environments that make use of a number of technologies which maked interactivity and simulated multi-dimensional study possible. The evolution of simple virtual representation of objects as exemplified by 360 degree rotational views and magnification options of detail have already been superseded by "modeled reconstruction and deconstruction" of virtual objects as exemplified in IBM's Digital Pieta project as well as by "virtual replacement of artifacts in situ
at their point of creation or discovery as experienced in the Eternal Egypt website (Tolva 2005). Although identified as 3D , such images are in reality 2D, but through various techniques like graphic modeling, digital video, and synching multiple digital stills of a real object using multimedia software like Flash (action software) and QuickTime to run it, three-dimensionality can essentially be simulated.
Any sampling of some of the most innovative uses of 3D imaging and modeling would include the Webby award-winning design of Second Story Interactive, the Monticello Explorer website, which includes the design and home of Thomas Jefferson. Visitors can navigate through a black and white 3D model of this famous home. Entering, one pans each room's contents clicking on architectural details or furnishings to reveal their detailed construction. Among other details, a parquet floor panel reveals the full schematics of its intricate weave of multiple pieces of wood though animation offered by Flash software. Clicking a camera icon reveals a photographic image of specific details. IBM Research's State Hermitage Museum website is another that includes numerous "virtual viewings" of objects. A virtual model of a "mechanical orchestra," an elaborate clock, rotates 360 degrees to reveal side panel doors and the mechanisms within. IBM's Visual Technological Department has developed "graphics, visualization, and image technologies for extracting, conveying, and visually communicating information" about art and historical objects (IBM Research).
Another IBM project was the aforementioned , detailed 3D model of Michelangelo's Pieta which made use of a scanner that measured the shape and appearance of every portion of the original sculpture. This scanned information was merged together to create an amazing virtual object that can be manipulated and examined unlike the real. Moreover, this website allows the viewer to imbed the Pieta in a number of virtual environments that virtually re-create it in its in situ circumstances. Other applications might include an object's point of creation or discovery. This evidences possibilities for new and interesting ways to re-contextualize objects and "help audiences see them and experience them differently" for possibly greater educational impact (Tolva 2005; Freedman 2003). The interactive viewer cannot peruse the whole but virtually dissect it and isolate each of its two figures for study. The more interactive features of this site, and others, only provide simplified virtual versions of the object whereas elements of lmited interaction are of higher resolution. This is also true of magnifying tools extant. Greater magnification of details results in decreased resolution. In the website Eternal Egypt , four directional arrows allow easy 360 degree rotational views of objects included, but virtual objects like the "Throne and Footrest of Tutankhamen" become increasingly fuzzy with use of the "zoom."
Simulated 3D has been around for quite some time. The National Research Council of Canada (NRC) experimented early with what 3D models could contribute to virtual display in Canadian museums (1995). Seven figurines were among the first objects scanned at high resolution in color for the purpose of interactive 3D virtual display. The intention was to allow visitors both a "microscopic" and "stereoscopic" view of the figurines using "active shutter glasses." This technique, intended for in-house computer kiosks, allowed enhancement of details, which were difficult to see on the real object. This use of 3D technology emphasized a potential use as a complementary element to traditional exhibitions and not as a substitute. In addition, the NRC has "designed and tested...3D laser imaging systems and processing algorithms with the aim of improving high-resolution modeling of complex objects and environments" for use in museum environments (NRC).
Earlier than any applications to museums, CAD (Computer-Aided Design) software assisted in the 3D digital rendering of structures and objects. CAT scanners and MRI machines provided 3D modeling of the human body and are well known for the purposes of medical diagnosis. Computer modeling is characterized by a digital wire frame or "mesh" that can be manipulated or allow one to render images, diagrams, or animations. One can "add, subtract [from], and sketch on this mesh. The models can be viewed from a variety of angles, simultaneously, as well as be rotated and viewed from different magnifications. More complicated modeling software, with the desired goal of close virtual reproduction of the real, requires the entering of mathematical coordinates in order to achieve exactitude. The relevancy of such multimedia tools to public interest is evidenced by Google's own purchase of the rights to and offering of the free downloadable software Sketch-Up, an "easy-to-learn" program that allows one to achieve the "conceptual stages of design" through 3D modeling. One of the popular, purchasable programs also available is 3DS MAX 2009 offering a menu of basic forms that can be pulled, prodded, stretched, among other possibilities, to achieve a desired form. The templates are all based on a polygon mesh that once shaped serves as a type of armature for additional characteristics, including texturing. Such a modeling program allows for full motion video, i.e. animation, of the rendered object or environment (Autodesk 2008).
For research, modeling may focus on the "shape and curvature" of real objects like "ceramic vessels, bones, and lithic [tools]." By plotting the measurements of height, width, surface area, and the like of the real on a malleable digital mesh, spatial definitions can be achieved. Such measurements can include even the smallest irregularities of curvature that succeed in creating an exact virtual rendering. This geometric type of modeling can be achieved through scanning the real object, with hardware like Cyberware Scanners, M15 & 3030. Multiple images of the scanned object are superimposed upon each other creating an on-screen three dimensional mesh version of it. Accuracy varies from one scanner to the next, and there is always another better model on the horizon (Rowe 2003;Voltoni 2007). Such accuracy could include "high resolution digital images" not unlike analog photos from the same vantage point," but interactivity is usually only possible at "20 frames per second." The limitation is due to the human brain's ability to detect "latency or jitter" with a greater number of frames as well as "loss of interactivity." Photorealism and smooth navigation are still not plausible "without some compromises" (Voltoni 2007). Not yet anyway.
These developments promise greater safety and preservation of real objects because they offer an alternative to the repeated handling necessitated by conventional exhibition and educational purposes. There is the possibility of effecting reduced labor in the composition of detailed condition reports and descriptions with the existence of 360 degree rotational views of objects through mouse clicks. Such a record would detail more about the object than is usually included in the several paragraphs of written description and the requisite one or two digital stills that comprise many digital collections databases. For the researcher, connoisseur, and the curious alike the visual totality of this virtual version could be made available for examination online. The museum space itself has from its conception made views of objects in their totality prohibitive, if not impossible.
There is urgency for greater consideration of developing technologies like 3D imaging and modeling objects in museum collections. Realizing virtual surrogates for real museum objects is a remedy for the prohibitions necessitated by the need to preserve and protect. Preserving and protecting has indirectly inhibited the learning styles of many in the museum and limited contexts by which objects can be enjoyed and appreciated. 3D imaging and modeling offers not only the best virtual surrogate to the real for the purpose of protecting and preserving it, but it allows a greater offering to the "seven ways of learning," specifically allowing tactile, kinesthetic, spatial experiences not usually options at most museums (Millicent Rogers). In addition, there are endless connections to be made by learners through the tools of multimedia interactivity that would allow greater possibilities for thematic programming and addressing every learning style.
One afternoon not long ago a student viewing the exhibit The Artist's Book as Volume of Knowledge by artist Angela Lorenz at the Addison Gallery of American Art in Andover, MA asked whether it was possible for a "board game" entitled South American Trading Game depicting a world map and the lasting effects of colonialism as its theme, could be removed from the glass case so he could play it. The museum educator leading this student's class held back a snicker and asked his peers why that wasn't possible. One dutifully answered that this was art and that it had been placed in the glass case so that people couldn't handle it, soil it, damage it. The fact you couldn't play it seemed the most obvious restriction, but that, strangely, wasn't verbalized. The fact is that this work was designed as a game with an important lesson to be learned from it. Games by their very definition involve play, but this particular one and others in the exhibit allowed no such interaction. It occurred to me that beyond merely looking at, hearing about, and verbally responding to this art and other works within a traditional museum experience, there are tactile and kinesthetic cues embodied that remain unanswered and are essentially stifled by the need to preserve and protect.
A consolation might be that these works by Lorenz are being seen and are inspiring discussion whereas many museum holdings and artist's creations are rarely, if ever, seeing the light of day, for they are packed away in archival boxes or stored on shelving in undisclosed storage facilities. A case in point is the Boston Children's Museum (BCM)'s greatest kept secret, its own teeming collection of cultural artifacts which largely dates from a time when museums for young visitors sought to create holdings identical to the ones for adults. This museum, and others like it, have dramatically changed their attitude about using museum objects for hands-on learning experiences off-site in area schools as they once did in the 1930s-1950s; subsequently, collections policies have changed regarding the acquisition of new objects because they are still wresting with what to do with what they have. One solution has been to de-accession allowing other institutions the opportunity to use these objections to serve their missions. Much remains though at the Children's Museum with no forseeable plans to get objects out of storage and exhibit them.
Not only has museum practice changed regarding these sometimes extremely valuable objects in some cases, but a revitalized emphasis on hands-on activities and interactive play with expendable and safe facsimiles may keep the sometimes dangerous and precious real McCoys once similarly used for education behind closed doors forever (Schwarzer 2001). Object cataloging, never of high priority, is frustratingly incomplete and sometimes nonexistent, and an effort to create a digital representation of each object is slowly underway, and this labor intensive and time consuming process may offer hope for bringing these objects, at least as a digital image, back into public view again.
What can be done? When asked this question, BCM Collections Manager Lindsay Richardson confided that the resources are not available for creating a complete web-based digital collections database any time soon. She dreams that one day, possibly during her tenure, this large eclectic treasure trove of samurai armor, cigar store Indians, doll houses, stuffed birds, and the like will benefit children through some type of digital interactive play. Collections that contain such artifacts may rarely if ever exhibit much of it. Their care and preservation come at great cost. Their fragility and value make public handling of them again out of the question. Exhibiting and loaning objects, no matter what preventative measures are taken, result in deterioration as well. Given this fact, many museums have become paralyzed by their obligation to preserve falling short of their one-time professed role of educating the public through these objects, but new purpose and function may correct this through the continued development and adoption of digital imaging and multimedia interactive software.
Museums may have their cake and eat it too, for those that have created a sampling of their holdings for the public with virtual objects and exhibitions have consequently limited future handling of the real thing. Digital versions can be viewed, researched, and be part of interactive play through the click of a mouse. Implementation of a variety of 3D imaging and modeling techniques have made these virtual objects publically accessible via website and in-house computer kiosks and an even more appealing surrogate for those who need to touch and manipulate to learn, to appreciate.
While some institutions have embraced the latest 3D imaging and modeling techniques in their offerings, many others have been slow to realize even digital collections databases which provide conventional two dimensional frontal views of each object. Creating 3D is possible with little expertise. It involves mounting a digital camera on a tripod for a series of stills. An object is placed in front of the camera and rotated at regular intervals between exposures. These stills could later be synched together and manipulated using Flash software to achieve the desired effect (Kumar 2007). Creating a virtual tour entails digitally photographing a 360 degree panoramic view of a museum space. A camera is positioned on a tripod in the center of the space and camera stills are taken at 30 degree intervals. This is repeated for "negative and positive pitch angles of 45 degrees" which can be synched together and manipulated relatively easily with satisfactory results. A scenario involving objects and an environment is achieved through a layering of elements.
Cost is often touted as the major obstacle to fully embracing new digital technologies. It is also pointed out that adopting such technology will mean that it will have to be replaced once the next innovation comes along. Given this limitation money could be better spent on something else. There is no denying that online software products and the hiring independent designers for implementing them with state of the art interactives is expensive proposition, but museums with little financial resources could seek sponsorship, pro-bono designers, and programmers who could be compensated through promotional and advertizing benefits. The process of developing and researching a virtual exhibition is equivalent to that of a physical exhibition, but "digital information is cheaper, faster, and more flexible" in the long run. Once the appropriate software has been secured and an expertise with the software has been gained, actual production of the virtual is relatively low in cost and expenditure of
man hours by comparison. It seems the "ideal medium for small museums, allowing them to diversify outreach efforts, experiment with innovative display, and develop a variety of advertizing campaigns." Christian Schickelgruber, Museum fur Volkerkunde, Vienna, claims he was able to develop a virtual exhibit for "approximately a seventh of the cost" of a physical one (Muller 2002).
Some institutions have made agreements with institutions of higher education whereby the digital images of their collection are licensed for educational use and made available through these institution's own databases. This has been a means by which smaller institutions have offset the cost of creating and maintaining digital assets. Such arrangements would likely also fall under the aegis of "fair use."
3D virtual objects and exhibition scenarios would necessitate the maintenance required of any asset, digital or real. Data entry and upkeep are an expense. Ensuring that your system is maintaining your digital assets and their functionality would be of especial concern with 3D interactive offerings. Without functionality and easy navigation such sources are useless. Specialized knowledge of these issues and the ability to diagnose existing problems would be important to collections management staff. When licensing multimedia software for the purpose of creating 3D images and/or offering interactivity, technical support would be a necessity. Depending on how technically savvy or willing your staff is to take on the responsibility of learning to create these assets and maintain them, would determine what portion of such a project would be realized by independent designers.
PEM, for example, contracts designers to help them realize their ideas by telling them what they can do and can't do with the particular content for a planned future virtual exhibition, usually to accompany one in the museum. Much of the construction process of writing code and testing functionality is left to PEM's own staff. This arrangement has evolved over the course of realizing many projects (Forrest 2007).
Some larger institutions have taken the lead in forming partnerships with other institutions to realize such projects, not to mention the sponsorship that often accompanies exhibitions themselves and provides funding for accompanying digital offerings. A partnership between London's Tate and New York's MET is among those that have realized the potential revenues generated by sites which include offerings from their collections virtually realized through cutting-edge technology. Museum websites often have twice the number of visitors as the physical museum, so "retail sales of museum merchandise on these sites is likely to "generate income, possibly substantial shared revenues." Such partnerships have reportedly reaped 6 billion dollars in earnings in recent years (Muller 2002:Reilly 2001).
A digital collections database augmented with 3D images promises quicker retrieval of collections information that would otherwise involve manually locating and removing objects from archival storage materials and subsequent hands-on physical examination. In addition, real objects need to be returned to their previous circumstances after answering inquiries, doing condition reports, or providing details to another institution that wishes to borrow the object for their future exhibition. Limiting handling of the real might be possible in many situations with accessibility to 3D images of them (Buck 18).
Virtual exhibitions place less strain on museum staffs because they are "restricted by time." They usually don't have the urgencies associated with real exhibitions. The virtual exhibition can remain online for extended periods with little maintenance. It can be archived online as well for public access seemingly in perpetuity, and, ideally, "such accessibility could lead to a density of information that might change people's ways of seeing, interpreting, and researching" (Muller 2002). Given the "cardinal rule of a good database" to not enter information more than once, if avoidable, adopting 3D images would ideally entail adding this information to already existing fields within your current database. The labor involved in adopting such a technology would therefore be minimized. This would be dependent on whether your current database can handle such large amounts of digital information.
In this age of heightened concern over carbon emissions and the consumption that fuels it, collections managers can take a leadership role in reducing their museum's environmental impact. Greater emphasis on virtual objects and exhibition may result in a reduction in the number of physical exhibitions which would subsequently result in the use of less packing materials for object exhibition, loans, and travel. It would also reduce the fuel use that comes with such transport (Loiko 2008).
With any type of digital or analog photographic reproduction of a work there may be issues of copyright. Knowing what your institution can and can't do with the objects in your collection is integral to any plan for either creating an online collections database or virtual exhibition. Given that educational purpose is often a museum's chief incentive for both virtual object development and interactvity, it is likely that the obstacles that for-profit institutions regularly face may be avoided through allowances for "fair use" for educational purpose granted to the non-profit museum. Researching the existence of copyright restrictions for your specific objects is always prudent.
Copyright may effect the digital assets themselves. Virtual objects may be considered original creative work, although it is derivative of something real within the collection. These would likely fall under separate copyright. This is evidenced by the precedence of distinctions between rights to real objects within the public domain and a museum's exclusive right to digital reproductions that they make publically available (Malaro 180). Museums should seek copyrights to all its digital assets as well as insure various safeguards, like watermarking, restricted downloading, and an inability to print such assets without license. These safeguards would be more applicable to specifically 3D images because reducing pixilation to insure low resolution images as a deterrent to theft would defeat the quality and therefore desirability of virtual surrogacy ultimately achieved through high resolution and interactivity (183).
The fear by some that museum visitors will eventually forgo the real for the virtual is unfounded. Evidence shows that "virtual versions of works of art increase people's desires to see the real thing" (Muller 2002). There is also no denying the existence of many who are still in denial about the role of digital media to extend amd enrich "the total museum experience." High resolution imagery has its flaws just like the physical museum. One can only concede that one won't replace the other but rather serve to complement each other (Cooper 2006). Some argue virtual objects, or what they call "digital-originals," have "the maximum possible likelihood of retaining all meaningful and relevant aspects of the original"; therefore, they will function "in just the same way as the original" (Smith 2000). The virtual does allow interaction that is prohibitive with the original , but the virtual also has a dependency on functioning, hardware, a network, and expertise that becomes an additional responsibility of collections management. The virtual isn't simply better than the real. A collection of appealing real objects is always needed to serve as the basis for any type of virtual reality a museum hopes to offer.
References
Autodesk 3ds Max. 9 April 2008.
http://usa.autodesk.com/adsk/sevlet/item?siteID=123112&id=11007364 Accessed 4.11.08
Buck, Rebecca A. and jean Allman Gilmore. The New Museum Registration Methods. Washington, DC: American Association of Museums, 1998.
Cooper, Jonathan. Archives & Museum Informatics. Museums and the Web 2006 Papers: Beyond the Online Museum: Participatory Virtual Exhibitions. March 22-25, 2006, Albuquerque, NM. http://www.artgallery.nsw.gov.au/ Accessed 3.28.08
Eternal Egypt. http://www.eternalegypt.org/ Accessed 3.28.08
Forrest, Jim, Web Creative Director, Peabody Essex Museum, Salem, MA, Guest Class Lecturer, Museums and New Media, Tufts University, 18 September 2007.
Free Library of Philadelphia. "Medieval Manuscripts." Digital Collection of Medieval and Renaissance Manuscripts. http://libww.library.phila.gov/medievalman/index.cfm Accessed 3.28.08
Freedman, Michael. Archives & Museum Informatics. Papers: Museums and the Web 2003. "Think Different: Combining Online Exhibitions and Offline Components to Gain New Understanding of Museum Permanent Collections." http://www.archimuse.com/mw2003/papers/feedman/freedman.html Accessed 3.28.08
IBM Research. "Visual Technologies Department." 2004. http://www.research.ibm.com/visualtechnologies/ Accessed 3.22.08
IBM Research. "Pieta." 2004 http://www.research.ibm.com/pieta/ Accessed 3.22.08
Image Dtabases. Medieval Studies Program Library Resources. "Digital Scriptorium." http://www.library.u/uc.edu/mdx.medstud/imageddtbs.html
Johnson, Brad. Archives & Museum Informatics. Papers: Museums and the Web 2003. "Disintegration and the Museum Web experience: Database or Documentary-Which Way Should We Go? http://www.archimuse.com/mw2003papers/Johnson/Johnson.html Accessed 3.20.08
Kumar, Vipan. "Making of a Virtualized Museum." (May 2007) Available at SSRN: http://ssrn.com/abstract+982782 Accessed 3.30.08
Lahanier, Christian, Genevieve Aitken, and Ruven Pillay. "Two dimensional multi-spectral digitization and three-dimensional modeling of easel paintings, pp. 30-42. ICOM-CC Triennial Preprints Documentation, ICOM-CC International Council of Museums/Committee of Conservation. http://icom-cc.museum/wg/Documentation/Newsletters/ Accessed 3.20.08
Lahanier, Christian, Denis Pitzalis, Oliver Feihl, Micheline Jeanlin, Francis Schmit. "Three-Dimensional Modeling for Archeological Objects for Conservation, Visualization, Color and Shape Characterization; Comparison of Details," pp. 43-51. ICOM-CC Triennial Preprints Documentation, ICOM-CC International Council of Museums/Committee of Conservation. http://icom-cc.museum/wg/Documentation/Newsletters/ Accessed 4.8.08
Loiko, Pat, Head Registrar, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, MA, Guest Lecturer, Tufts University, 21 February 2008.
Malaro, Marie C. A Legal Primer on Managing Museum Collections. Washington, DC: Smithsonian Books, 1998.
Millicent Rogers Museum of Northern New Mexico. "Seven Ways of Learning." Squash Blossom & Stars. http://www.milicentrogers.org/seven_ways_of_learning.htm Accessed 4.20.08
Explorer Monticello. http://www.explorer.monticello.org/ Accessed 4.10.08
Muller, Klaus. "Going Global: Reaching Out for the Online Visitor." Museum News, Sept./Oct. 2002, Vol.81, No.5.
Museum of Fine Arts. http://www.mfa.org/dynamic/sub/ctr_link_url_1341.pdf Accessed 4.8.08
National Research Council/Canada. "3D Virtual Museum Display and Applications." http://iit-iti.nrc-cnrc.gc.ca/vit-tiv/display-exhibit_e.html Accessed 3.28.08
Peabody Essex Museum. Joseph Cornell; Navigating the Imagination. http://www.pem.org/Cornell/ Accessed 4.2.08
Peabody Essex Museum. Art and Culture Center. Origami Now! http://www.pem.org/visit/art-nature.php Accessed 4.2.08
Reilly Jr., Bernard F. "Merging and Diverging: New International Business Models from the Web." Museum News, Jan./Feb. 2001, Vol.80, No.1.
Rowe, Jeremy, and Anshuman Razdan. Archives & Museum Informatics. Papers/Museums and the Web 2003; A Prototype Digital Library for 3D Collections: Tools to capture, Model, Analyze, Query Complex 3D Data. http://www.archimuse.com/mw2003/papers/rowe/rowe.html Accessed 4.13.08
Schwarzer. Marjorie. "Art & Gadgetry: the Future of the Museum." Museum News, July/Aug. 2001, Vol. 80, No.4.
Smith, Abby. "Authenticity in Perspective." Council on Library & Information resources (CLIR). 25 May 2000. http://www.clir.org/pubs/reports/pub92/Smith.html Accessed 4.13.08
van Dijk, Dick. Archives & Museum Informatics. Papers/Museums and the Web 2007: Operation Sigismund; Bringing An Archive Into Play. http://www.archimuse.com/mw2007/papers/vanDijk/vanDijk.html
Voltoni, F., and A. Beraldin, S. El-Hakim, and L.Gonzo. "Photorealistic 3D Modeling Applied to Cultural Heritage." Stock, Oliver, and Massimo Zancanaro, Eds. PEACH-Intelligent interfaces for Museum Visits, NY: Springer, 2007. http://mariovittone.com/2010/05/154/http://mariovittone.com/2010/05/154/
This blog is dedicated to all museum goers. You can be a museum professional or simply a member of the public who loves to frequent science, art, and history museums, historical houses, historical societies, archives, zoos, aquariums, and the like. This blog is for the curious and for those who are critical and like to share their experiences.
Sunday, November 16, 2008
Wednesday, September 3, 2008
Museum Marketing 21st Century Style
Having visited numerous small to medium size museums, historical societies, and historical houses in the past six months, I have become acutely aware of some of the challenges that especially smaller institutions face in the wake of an ever increasing competition for the time of American audiences. Not only has "television, mass media, and electronic media ...changed the public’s recreational activities," but "for-profit corporations" have taken on an increasing role in developing "exhibitions, cultural programming, and ‘edutainment’" that continues to overshadow and threaten especially small institutions with small budgets. This competition has made the necessity for such small institutions as the local historical society to focus more directly than ever before on marketing strategies (Genoways and Ireland 258, 260).
"Marketing," with its traditions of competition, and sometimes cut-throat at that, has often been seen by the museum community as something for them to resist. What hasn't been stressed enough among board members, administrators, and staffs, is that marketing strategies can make such institutions greater at serving their audiences, for successful marketing strategies are founded on an understanding of the public and their needs, or perceived needs. Small institutions, like the local historical society, need to step up to the plate and deliver new and attractive ways of "presenting themselves." They must drive the point home that they are the "‘the real thing,’" a place where "meaningful objects and trustworthy information" reside.
The best strategy for this may simply be to have a greater role in the lives of the public. In doing this they negate all their fears about taking on the agenda of marketing, for greater involvement in the community through education offerings like storytime hours for children, after school programs, and school visits may alone boost exposure and ultimately greater patronage without going the road of the hard sell. These institutions also need to embrace the history of more than merely the elite of the past, present other periods in history other than the distant past, and, finally, take on the untraditional role of documenting and presenting their community’s more recent past through the mediums of our own time—digital photography and audio in order to meet market needs.
So "taking on the point of view of visitors," or potential visitors, is a key to greater success, and it may mean that some institutions must transcend merely narratives about the 17th-19th centuries and market to the current demand for late twentieth century nostalgia by baby boomers and Gen-Xers. This may be a way to both preserve their missions, draw people in for their long existing collections, remain relevant, and grow. In saying this, I am reminded of institutions in which very dedicated individuals scratch their heads and wonder why the public isn’t coming; they and their institutions have remained static while the rest of the world have passed them by.
What might be some of the specific marketing strategies that might make such institutions more obviously relevant in the public’s eye? The Andover Historical Society in Massachusetts has sought to reinvent how their community members come to know about their offerings. They have struck upon the idea of organizing a farmer’s market where one no longer existed. Small farms are all over its surrounding community. A high school student at the nearby Phillip’s Academy actually initiated the idea when she contacted the Society and inquired about whether a farmer's market presently existed for her to sell produce from. The Society sent out feelers about the possibility of one being created by them, and many local farmers jumped at the opportunity.
The Historical Society provided rental space for these farmers on their property next to their historical house headquarters thus taking an active role in the making of history in their community rather than merely preserving and sharing it. This scheme not only brings in revenues from the rental spaces but also succeeds at bringing a significant number of people on the society’s grounds whereby they could be invited in and be provided with outdoor as well as indoor programming. There was significant free press coverage as a result of the success of this venture, and this has brought even more people in contact with the Society’s offerings. In sum, this was a public relations coup. Many locals admitted that they never knew anything about the Historical Society, although they passed it daily.
There is the promise of bringing in a whole new demographic with such types of ventures, for the attendance previous to this was almost exclusively senior citizens seeking genealogical information from the Society’s research facilities. The market could also serve thematically with the extant 19th century offerings of this site. Workshops offering instruction in crafts are offered and could be further developed in conjunction with this active agricultural endeavor. Historical societies have other opportunities of making that greater connect with the public. Other opportunities might include providing "edutainment" like summer film festivals that include foreign and art titles not served by national cinema chains and additional discussion forums. Viewing could be offered outdoors.
With the number of local cable channels available today small museums might present some of their holdings in televised exhibits, which may be as simple as having a curator or scholar talk about a piece that stands in front of him or her. Video tours of historical houses and sites and re-enactments could be the stuff of such cable programming created by volunteers and initiated by the historical society. Digital videotaping has made such a possibility affordable. Programming could also be assisted with cooperative partnerships with local schools and colleges of budding historians and media production professionals.
It seems logical that a local historical society could market itself by taking a more active role in the technologies that pose a threat to their survival. They could establish greater relevancy by actively participating in the current documentation of a community for future posterity. What about all the information the living have about their own lives? Oral histories that involve both video and audio should be integral to a evolving mission for local historical societies. How about sponsoring reunions of local garage bands from the 60s, 70s, and 80s? Have them play for the community. Record this for posterity, for it is unlikely that this part of a communities history will be ignored, lost, and supplanted by traditional collecting practices. Do historical societies have an obligation to preserve more recent history of a community? I think they do. Adapting a society’s collecting focus goes hand-in-hand with marketing the institution to a younger public; these, after all, will inherit the institution and will be responsible for its future survival.
References
Genoways, Hugh H. and Lynne M. Ireland. Museum Administration: An Introduction. Rowman Altamira, 2003.
"Marketing," with its traditions of competition, and sometimes cut-throat at that, has often been seen by the museum community as something for them to resist. What hasn't been stressed enough among board members, administrators, and staffs, is that marketing strategies can make such institutions greater at serving their audiences, for successful marketing strategies are founded on an understanding of the public and their needs, or perceived needs. Small institutions, like the local historical society, need to step up to the plate and deliver new and attractive ways of "presenting themselves." They must drive the point home that they are the "‘the real thing,’" a place where "meaningful objects and trustworthy information" reside.
The best strategy for this may simply be to have a greater role in the lives of the public. In doing this they negate all their fears about taking on the agenda of marketing, for greater involvement in the community through education offerings like storytime hours for children, after school programs, and school visits may alone boost exposure and ultimately greater patronage without going the road of the hard sell. These institutions also need to embrace the history of more than merely the elite of the past, present other periods in history other than the distant past, and, finally, take on the untraditional role of documenting and presenting their community’s more recent past through the mediums of our own time—digital photography and audio in order to meet market needs.
So "taking on the point of view of visitors," or potential visitors, is a key to greater success, and it may mean that some institutions must transcend merely narratives about the 17th-19th centuries and market to the current demand for late twentieth century nostalgia by baby boomers and Gen-Xers. This may be a way to both preserve their missions, draw people in for their long existing collections, remain relevant, and grow. In saying this, I am reminded of institutions in which very dedicated individuals scratch their heads and wonder why the public isn’t coming; they and their institutions have remained static while the rest of the world have passed them by.
What might be some of the specific marketing strategies that might make such institutions more obviously relevant in the public’s eye? The Andover Historical Society in Massachusetts has sought to reinvent how their community members come to know about their offerings. They have struck upon the idea of organizing a farmer’s market where one no longer existed. Small farms are all over its surrounding community. A high school student at the nearby Phillip’s Academy actually initiated the idea when she contacted the Society and inquired about whether a farmer's market presently existed for her to sell produce from. The Society sent out feelers about the possibility of one being created by them, and many local farmers jumped at the opportunity.
The Historical Society provided rental space for these farmers on their property next to their historical house headquarters thus taking an active role in the making of history in their community rather than merely preserving and sharing it. This scheme not only brings in revenues from the rental spaces but also succeeds at bringing a significant number of people on the society’s grounds whereby they could be invited in and be provided with outdoor as well as indoor programming. There was significant free press coverage as a result of the success of this venture, and this has brought even more people in contact with the Society’s offerings. In sum, this was a public relations coup. Many locals admitted that they never knew anything about the Historical Society, although they passed it daily.
There is the promise of bringing in a whole new demographic with such types of ventures, for the attendance previous to this was almost exclusively senior citizens seeking genealogical information from the Society’s research facilities. The market could also serve thematically with the extant 19th century offerings of this site. Workshops offering instruction in crafts are offered and could be further developed in conjunction with this active agricultural endeavor. Historical societies have other opportunities of making that greater connect with the public. Other opportunities might include providing "edutainment" like summer film festivals that include foreign and art titles not served by national cinema chains and additional discussion forums. Viewing could be offered outdoors.
With the number of local cable channels available today small museums might present some of their holdings in televised exhibits, which may be as simple as having a curator or scholar talk about a piece that stands in front of him or her. Video tours of historical houses and sites and re-enactments could be the stuff of such cable programming created by volunteers and initiated by the historical society. Digital videotaping has made such a possibility affordable. Programming could also be assisted with cooperative partnerships with local schools and colleges of budding historians and media production professionals.
It seems logical that a local historical society could market itself by taking a more active role in the technologies that pose a threat to their survival. They could establish greater relevancy by actively participating in the current documentation of a community for future posterity. What about all the information the living have about their own lives? Oral histories that involve both video and audio should be integral to a evolving mission for local historical societies. How about sponsoring reunions of local garage bands from the 60s, 70s, and 80s? Have them play for the community. Record this for posterity, for it is unlikely that this part of a communities history will be ignored, lost, and supplanted by traditional collecting practices. Do historical societies have an obligation to preserve more recent history of a community? I think they do. Adapting a society’s collecting focus goes hand-in-hand with marketing the institution to a younger public; these, after all, will inherit the institution and will be responsible for its future survival.
References
Genoways, Hugh H. and Lynne M. Ireland. Museum Administration: An Introduction. Rowman Altamira, 2003.
Monday, April 28, 2008
Considering 3D Virtual Surrogates for Real Museum Objects
With the undeniable presence of digital technology in our lives and Web 2.0 use among an ever increasing demographic not limited to the under 30, museums cannot escape the inevitability of becoming either cultural learning organizations "that continue their traditional functions alongside new functions" or simply become obsolete (Moraga 2007). Perhaps, more correctly, museums might be more effectively meeting the responsibility of educating the public through the "science-like access to information" and the "documentary film-like storytelling qualities" that characterize online virtual objects and interactivity than tthrough traditional exhibitions. Many museums are making that shift from being "information interpreters to information providers" (Johnson 2003;Muller 2002).
The physical museum may become more of a repository for objects safely stored away and rarely physically exhibited while "virtual surrogates that can withstand manipulation" are presented instead, taking on the function of educating greater numbers of the public than ever before (Chittenden 2007).This scenario is not limited to one replacing the other but rather virtual surrogates functioning simultaneously or on a more regular basis with the realin sometimes multiple ands differeing contexts and narratives by authors from different cultures and distant museums on other websites in addition to allowing interactive play and study.
The museum has always been a place for learning , but learning in the age of Web 2.0 enables contact with more and different types of learners. It allows different kinds of exposure to art and artifacts which consequently make it more contributive to "innovation and growth." Although "the technological migration from material to virtual artifact is at present gradual," it is immediately worth considering that real objects may become more removed from the "the arena of public display." More museums will need to understand the underlying interpretive strategies used in and educational gains received from the virtual by a new generation of computer-savvy visitors in order for them to remain relevant to their needs and desires (Chittenden 2007).
The physical museum may become more of a repository for objects safely stored away and rarely physically exhibited while "virtual surrogates that can withstand manipulation" are presented instead, taking on the function of educating greater numbers of the public than ever before (Chittenden 2007).This scenario is not limited to one replacing the other but rather virtual surrogates functioning simultaneously or on a more regular basis with the realin sometimes multiple ands differeing contexts and narratives by authors from different cultures and distant museums on other websites in addition to allowing interactive play and study.
The museum has always been a place for learning , but learning in the age of Web 2.0 enables contact with more and different types of learners. It allows different kinds of exposure to art and artifacts which consequently make it more contributive to "innovation and growth." Although "the technological migration from material to virtual artifact is at present gradual," it is immediately worth considering that real objects may become more removed from the "the arena of public display." More museums will need to understand the underlying interpretive strategies used in and educational gains received from the virtual by a new generation of computer-savvy visitors in order for them to remain relevant to their needs and desires (Chittenden 2007).
Sunday, March 30, 2008
Should Museums Aim to Produce Emotional Responses From Visitors?
In considering whether museums should aim to produce emotional responses from visitors, it might be prudent to consider some historical particulars of American art and exhibition that I believe are very pertinent to answering this question in an American context. America’s "Hudson River School" contributed to an early commodification of art in America. Its wilderness imagery served emotively to develop a national identity among citizens of a new nation. So there is this early pairing of art’s ability to emote a particular response from a public, to serve in developing a national identity, and to serve as a commodity, a product. Public exhibiting venues also evolved around this time too, and one phenomena that I see especially pertinent to the above question is that some early American art exhibitions exemplified a perceived need to accentuate the emotive power of representations of sublime wilderness depicted in those early American canvases.
Leading artist Albert Bierstadt orchestrated an Indian settlement in NYC to promote his paintings of America’s primordial past and disappearing far western frontier for urbanites. Paintings by Frederick Church, like Cotopaxi and The Heart of the Andes, were not simply displayed in a frame on the wall of a white cube. They were more effectively exhibited surrounded by plants from the South American destinations they depicted and lit by gas lighting in ways that sought to recreate the real. Additionally, the simulated view of landscape sought the illusion of height and distance for audiences which would ideally emote the special fear mixed with pleasure, the sublime, that the real subject matter was said to summon. Church and others had a product to sell, and they knew how to package it. Summoning awe, disturbance, and excitement was the goal of these nineteenth century artists before the development of art museums, and thus it came to inform the development of public art exhibition itself. Given the choice of simply placing art in a frame in the white cube or orchestrating some spectacle or narrative that can evoke emotions from many, the choice is an obvious one. Successful exhibitions are often defined as much for the good business sense that made them possible as the art work in them. This has predicated the need for the more specular, the more shocking, as one upmanship is played out in the museum world year after year.
Exhibitions, like the Brooklyn Museum’s more infamous showing of Damien Hurst’s Sensations is a more recent example of this phenomena. If this exhibition didn’t summon all kinds of emotions then nothing will. People knew that this was its intent and flocked to it in record numbers. Whether you want to debate whether this was art or not is another question, but I can remember that people I knew who never talked about such questions of aesthetics talked about them and even more rarely went to see what all the brouhaha was about. That makes me believe that such an "aim" is a good thing for both art and museums for it gets the public to the museum; furthermore, it may be necessitated when museums are forced like any other business for the attentions of the public in this brutally competitive market economy. Effecting emotion has obviously worked to keep many museums competitive in a race for the attention of a culture increasingly bombarded by diversions and choices.
More obviously this "aim" has been affirmed by an ever increasing number of museums that create new narratives and present them through new mediums of exhibition. Consider the use of web sites with digital audio, video, and interactive technology that convey ideas and imagery like never before, and summon our emotions like never before. Some recent examples of the use of these new tools to convey the powerful narratives that museums are capable of include the heart wrenching tragedy of genocide in the Congo ( Ripples of Genocide: Journey through Eastern Congo http://www.ushmm.org/museum/exhibit/online/congojournal/ ) as well as a revisitation of the Holocaust ( Life After the Holocaust http://www.ushmmorg/museum/exhibit/online/life_after_holocaust ), among others.
These presentations, exhibitions, and productions have been tailored to evoke emotions garnering empathy, sympathy, understanding, and, ultimately, enlightening us the seeds of such inhumanity and, ultimately, stifling it. The museum’s ability to use new technologies to produce a positive emotion in response to these particular injustices and for the good of all alone makes a very convincing argument in favor of their use.
Leading artist Albert Bierstadt orchestrated an Indian settlement in NYC to promote his paintings of America’s primordial past and disappearing far western frontier for urbanites. Paintings by Frederick Church, like Cotopaxi and The Heart of the Andes, were not simply displayed in a frame on the wall of a white cube. They were more effectively exhibited surrounded by plants from the South American destinations they depicted and lit by gas lighting in ways that sought to recreate the real. Additionally, the simulated view of landscape sought the illusion of height and distance for audiences which would ideally emote the special fear mixed with pleasure, the sublime, that the real subject matter was said to summon. Church and others had a product to sell, and they knew how to package it. Summoning awe, disturbance, and excitement was the goal of these nineteenth century artists before the development of art museums, and thus it came to inform the development of public art exhibition itself. Given the choice of simply placing art in a frame in the white cube or orchestrating some spectacle or narrative that can evoke emotions from many, the choice is an obvious one. Successful exhibitions are often defined as much for the good business sense that made them possible as the art work in them. This has predicated the need for the more specular, the more shocking, as one upmanship is played out in the museum world year after year.
Exhibitions, like the Brooklyn Museum’s more infamous showing of Damien Hurst’s Sensations is a more recent example of this phenomena. If this exhibition didn’t summon all kinds of emotions then nothing will. People knew that this was its intent and flocked to it in record numbers. Whether you want to debate whether this was art or not is another question, but I can remember that people I knew who never talked about such questions of aesthetics talked about them and even more rarely went to see what all the brouhaha was about. That makes me believe that such an "aim" is a good thing for both art and museums for it gets the public to the museum; furthermore, it may be necessitated when museums are forced like any other business for the attentions of the public in this brutally competitive market economy. Effecting emotion has obviously worked to keep many museums competitive in a race for the attention of a culture increasingly bombarded by diversions and choices.
More obviously this "aim" has been affirmed by an ever increasing number of museums that create new narratives and present them through new mediums of exhibition. Consider the use of web sites with digital audio, video, and interactive technology that convey ideas and imagery like never before, and summon our emotions like never before. Some recent examples of the use of these new tools to convey the powerful narratives that museums are capable of include the heart wrenching tragedy of genocide in the Congo ( Ripples of Genocide: Journey through Eastern Congo http://www.ushmm.org/museum/exhibit/online/congojournal/ ) as well as a revisitation of the Holocaust ( Life After the Holocaust http://www.ushmmorg/museum/exhibit/online/life_after_holocaust ), among others.
These presentations, exhibitions, and productions have been tailored to evoke emotions garnering empathy, sympathy, understanding, and, ultimately, enlightening us the seeds of such inhumanity and, ultimately, stifling it. The museum’s ability to use new technologies to produce a positive emotion in response to these particular injustices and for the good of all alone makes a very convincing argument in favor of their use.
Saturday, March 1, 2008
A Gallery Under The Sun: The Origins of the Sculpture Park and Gardens
On a visit to antebellum America, Lady Emmeline Stuart Wortley of England was struck by the lack of sculpture. The sculpture she did see in the rural cemeteries consusted largely of grave markers and memorials in the ancient geometry of the Romans, Greeks, and the Egyptians, but there were occasional sculptures in the round and bas-reliefs exemplifying the budding skills of the nation's artists to capture the human form, foliage, and flower. The circumstances for the public's appreciation for these was largely ancillary, for the focus of the cemetery was more importantly the memorialization of the dead as well as the appreciation of the natural beauty surrounding these blocks of stone. The sculpture was more specifically funerary art in forms that almost exclusively included variations on the ancient Egyptian stele, obelisks, and the repetitive classical pedestal and shaft form.
There were also on rare occasions fully articulated three dimensional organic forms imitative of tree trunks and sawn logs in marble, yet these were historically linked with the practice of engraving two dimensional likenesses of trees, flowers, vines, and plant life that had characterized much funerary art from the early colonial period until the nineteenth century. These funerary pieces seemed to almost take root in their natural surroundings to the point of sometimes being mistaken for real trees and real logs as they weathered with time. These contrasted with the seemingly incongruent intrusions of the classically inspired square and rectangular monuments. Three-dimensional sculpture imitative of the characteristics of the surrounding landscape was almost non-existent in the antebellum era.
The public park was the natural progression of rural cemetery design, and the early cemetery ( the word "cemetery" not coming into common use until the second decade of the 19th century in America) similarly intended as a place for public leisure in addition to being a final resting place for the dead. There was flora and foliage in an arrangement that at times attempted to mimic the randomness of wilderness growth. There were also similar arrangements of stone and an attempt to accentuate topographies with inclines for the purpose of vigorous walks and vistas requisite for quiet contemplation. These were in reality only an approximation of the real wilderness; they were more accurately a sanitized version oif the real that served to supplant everything deemed undesirable about the wilderness which ever greater numbers fantisized about experiencing in America's far western frontier by the mid 19th century. For an intelligensia, the rural cemetery, and later the public park, had a proscribed civic role. Through its offering of greenery and solitude act as balm to cure the ills of urban life. It was the sheer lack of greenery and recreational space in the wake of massive immigration and subsequent overcrowding and joblessness in the burgeoning cities of antebellum America that made such places a necessity. Some likened such projects as a release valve to an imminent collapse of all that they valued. While the early cemetery and park did serve as a temporary release for many urban Americans, it was the opportunities that lay to the West, in America's last wilderness destination, that was a more permanent release from the contraints of urban life.
Frederick Law Olmstead was largely responsible for developing the model of the public park in America's urban centers; the prohibition of burials in these new public sites was the major deviation from the earlier rural cemetery design. Like the cemetery, memorials in stone were a characteristic of the public park too and continue to be. This sculpture similarly reflected the era’s taste for the classical. Sculpture continued to be incongruent with the then sought-after naturalness of random growth that Olmstead accomplished through engineered plantings, constructed rock formations, and graded swells. No sculpture was expressly created for the purpose of a wilderness space exuding any type of harmony with its setting. No sculpture from this time expressed a particularly environmental relationship whereby it both accentuated and became an extension of its intended natural surroundings.
The outdoor sculpture garden, as we know it, was realized much later with Brookgreen Gardens in South Carolina in the early 1930s, but it too chose sculpture that was both classical, figurative, and seemingly incongruent. The sculpture garden of the Museum of Modern Art (MOMA) was among the first to depart from the tradition of using only classical designs of sculpture in the outdoors; during the same decade works by twentieth-century modern artists would offer a radical departure from how sculpture and what sculpture would inhabit outdoor space (McCarthy 4). But MOMA, as an inner city site, lacked both the size and character of the rural setting realized in both earlier cemeteries and public parks. These sculptures were never site-specific, and this "garden" merely served as an enclave to see and appreciate these sculptures. They were not intended to be interactive or serve any purpose connected to a specifically natural setting. This concept would take longer to evolve.
So when was sculpture expressly created with an interactive and complementary function to a specific natural setting? What were its specific characteristics? And how did it hope to realize this function in an environmental surrounding? Do sculptures from the twentieth and twenty-first century share anything in common with the goals of antebellum rural cemetery design? In order to answer these questions it will be necessary to both identify a selection of twentieth and twenty-first century artists and their works that are both site-specific and consider their planning, realization, and installation. Among the artists that might be considered is Isamu Noguchi, whose work suggests strong ties with both western and eastern aesthetic traditions. These aesthetic identities might also be considered influential to other works of the period given the cultural exchanges of the twentieth century.
In particular, Noguchi’s installation entitled Momo Taro (1977) at Storm King Art Center in Mountainville, New York is of particular interest because it has been intentionally embedded by the artist into the site’s soil becoming literally one with the landscape (McCarthy 83). More recent artists like Maya Lin have achieved similar results in work that appears to naturally emerge from the landscape. Lin's skating rink park in Grand Rapids, Michigan as well as her more famous Vietnam Memorial in Washington, DC provide seemingly a symbiosis of sculpture and an extant topography (Sollins).
The work of artist Robert Smithson offers other examples of site-specific sculpture, but, unlike the work of Noguchi and others, his compositions consist of altered landscapes through either an addition or subtraction of natural materials. These he identified as "Earthworks." What makes Earthworks like Spiral Jetty (1970) particularly unique is that it is a work planned to never be finished, for the artist created an altered state of a landscape that continues to be redefined through nature’s effects on it. The rocks and gravel of its spiral shaped form continue to be salinized as a result of its situation within Utah’s Great Salt Lake. Over the past decades salt crystals have produced a layered residue on the jetty which is dramatically illuminated by the desert sun.
Smithson also, through what he defined as "nonsites," also separated raw material from their natural setting and reconfigured them with the addition of other materials like glass and mirror shards. These works could be likened to landscape vignettes within the ubiquitous white cube known as the indoor gallery space. These works suggest further connection with the American art tradition of transmuting wilderness imagery if we consider that the rural cemetery of antebellum America was literally a reconfiguration of wild nature for public consumption (Tsai 29-31).
While the rural cemetery ideally served the didactic purpose of exempifying how greenery and natural setting served antebellum society in positive ways. Building upon this earlier concept of making the preservation of the last vestiges of wild America beyond the city limits implicit in both rural cemetery design and public parks, contemporary artists like Mel Chin have created site-specific installations that draw attention to the chronological progression of the American landscape including the later threat of environmental pollution in order to draw attention to this condition. In his Minneapolis, Minnesota work Revival Field (1990), with agronomist R.L Chaney, his medium for three-dimensional outdoor sculpture has become the soil and plants of a specific ecology itself. This ecology is one tainted by heavy metal pollutants from area industrialization. Through cultivation of specific plants known as "hyperacumulators" within this defined area of fallow industrially tainted land, heavy metals are being drawn out through a process of engineered botanical cleansing. The plants have subsequently been harvested and processed whereby the heavy metals have been reclaimed for either disposed for further use (Sollins).
Further exploration of these more recent artists and their work promises further understanding of a continued concern for versions of nature and wilderness in American art, their transmutation, and their transmittance. Unique to this particular time, these works exemplify not only the realization of sculptures that include landscape itself but the use of nature’s forces to realize continuously altered states of appearance. Like the material culture of nineteenth century rural cemeteries and public parks, these more recent works promise a continued dialogue about nature; its aesthetic value, its didactic function, its civic function, and the necessity for its preservation.
References
Sollins, Susan and Susan Dowling, Art:21— Art in the Twenty-First Century, Season One, PBS Home Video, 2003.
Tsai, Eugene. "Robert Smithson: Plotting a Line from Passaic, New Jersey to Amarillo, Texas." Robert Smithson, Ed. Eugene Tsai with Cornelia Butler, The Museum of Contemporary Art, LA, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2004.
There were also on rare occasions fully articulated three dimensional organic forms imitative of tree trunks and sawn logs in marble, yet these were historically linked with the practice of engraving two dimensional likenesses of trees, flowers, vines, and plant life that had characterized much funerary art from the early colonial period until the nineteenth century. These funerary pieces seemed to almost take root in their natural surroundings to the point of sometimes being mistaken for real trees and real logs as they weathered with time. These contrasted with the seemingly incongruent intrusions of the classically inspired square and rectangular monuments. Three-dimensional sculpture imitative of the characteristics of the surrounding landscape was almost non-existent in the antebellum era.
The public park was the natural progression of rural cemetery design, and the early cemetery ( the word "cemetery" not coming into common use until the second decade of the 19th century in America) similarly intended as a place for public leisure in addition to being a final resting place for the dead. There was flora and foliage in an arrangement that at times attempted to mimic the randomness of wilderness growth. There were also similar arrangements of stone and an attempt to accentuate topographies with inclines for the purpose of vigorous walks and vistas requisite for quiet contemplation. These were in reality only an approximation of the real wilderness; they were more accurately a sanitized version oif the real that served to supplant everything deemed undesirable about the wilderness which ever greater numbers fantisized about experiencing in America's far western frontier by the mid 19th century. For an intelligensia, the rural cemetery, and later the public park, had a proscribed civic role. Through its offering of greenery and solitude act as balm to cure the ills of urban life. It was the sheer lack of greenery and recreational space in the wake of massive immigration and subsequent overcrowding and joblessness in the burgeoning cities of antebellum America that made such places a necessity. Some likened such projects as a release valve to an imminent collapse of all that they valued. While the early cemetery and park did serve as a temporary release for many urban Americans, it was the opportunities that lay to the West, in America's last wilderness destination, that was a more permanent release from the contraints of urban life.
Frederick Law Olmstead was largely responsible for developing the model of the public park in America's urban centers; the prohibition of burials in these new public sites was the major deviation from the earlier rural cemetery design. Like the cemetery, memorials in stone were a characteristic of the public park too and continue to be. This sculpture similarly reflected the era’s taste for the classical. Sculpture continued to be incongruent with the then sought-after naturalness of random growth that Olmstead accomplished through engineered plantings, constructed rock formations, and graded swells. No sculpture was expressly created for the purpose of a wilderness space exuding any type of harmony with its setting. No sculpture from this time expressed a particularly environmental relationship whereby it both accentuated and became an extension of its intended natural surroundings.
The outdoor sculpture garden, as we know it, was realized much later with Brookgreen Gardens in South Carolina in the early 1930s, but it too chose sculpture that was both classical, figurative, and seemingly incongruent. The sculpture garden of the Museum of Modern Art (MOMA) was among the first to depart from the tradition of using only classical designs of sculpture in the outdoors; during the same decade works by twentieth-century modern artists would offer a radical departure from how sculpture and what sculpture would inhabit outdoor space (McCarthy 4). But MOMA, as an inner city site, lacked both the size and character of the rural setting realized in both earlier cemeteries and public parks. These sculptures were never site-specific, and this "garden" merely served as an enclave to see and appreciate these sculptures. They were not intended to be interactive or serve any purpose connected to a specifically natural setting. This concept would take longer to evolve.
So when was sculpture expressly created with an interactive and complementary function to a specific natural setting? What were its specific characteristics? And how did it hope to realize this function in an environmental surrounding? Do sculptures from the twentieth and twenty-first century share anything in common with the goals of antebellum rural cemetery design? In order to answer these questions it will be necessary to both identify a selection of twentieth and twenty-first century artists and their works that are both site-specific and consider their planning, realization, and installation. Among the artists that might be considered is Isamu Noguchi, whose work suggests strong ties with both western and eastern aesthetic traditions. These aesthetic identities might also be considered influential to other works of the period given the cultural exchanges of the twentieth century.
In particular, Noguchi’s installation entitled Momo Taro (1977) at Storm King Art Center in Mountainville, New York is of particular interest because it has been intentionally embedded by the artist into the site’s soil becoming literally one with the landscape (McCarthy 83). More recent artists like Maya Lin have achieved similar results in work that appears to naturally emerge from the landscape. Lin's skating rink park in Grand Rapids, Michigan as well as her more famous Vietnam Memorial in Washington, DC provide seemingly a symbiosis of sculpture and an extant topography (Sollins).
The work of artist Robert Smithson offers other examples of site-specific sculpture, but, unlike the work of Noguchi and others, his compositions consist of altered landscapes through either an addition or subtraction of natural materials. These he identified as "Earthworks." What makes Earthworks like Spiral Jetty (1970) particularly unique is that it is a work planned to never be finished, for the artist created an altered state of a landscape that continues to be redefined through nature’s effects on it. The rocks and gravel of its spiral shaped form continue to be salinized as a result of its situation within Utah’s Great Salt Lake. Over the past decades salt crystals have produced a layered residue on the jetty which is dramatically illuminated by the desert sun.
Smithson also, through what he defined as "nonsites," also separated raw material from their natural setting and reconfigured them with the addition of other materials like glass and mirror shards. These works could be likened to landscape vignettes within the ubiquitous white cube known as the indoor gallery space. These works suggest further connection with the American art tradition of transmuting wilderness imagery if we consider that the rural cemetery of antebellum America was literally a reconfiguration of wild nature for public consumption (Tsai 29-31).
While the rural cemetery ideally served the didactic purpose of exempifying how greenery and natural setting served antebellum society in positive ways. Building upon this earlier concept of making the preservation of the last vestiges of wild America beyond the city limits implicit in both rural cemetery design and public parks, contemporary artists like Mel Chin have created site-specific installations that draw attention to the chronological progression of the American landscape including the later threat of environmental pollution in order to draw attention to this condition. In his Minneapolis, Minnesota work Revival Field (1990), with agronomist R.L Chaney, his medium for three-dimensional outdoor sculpture has become the soil and plants of a specific ecology itself. This ecology is one tainted by heavy metal pollutants from area industrialization. Through cultivation of specific plants known as "hyperacumulators" within this defined area of fallow industrially tainted land, heavy metals are being drawn out through a process of engineered botanical cleansing. The plants have subsequently been harvested and processed whereby the heavy metals have been reclaimed for either disposed for further use (Sollins).
Further exploration of these more recent artists and their work promises further understanding of a continued concern for versions of nature and wilderness in American art, their transmutation, and their transmittance. Unique to this particular time, these works exemplify not only the realization of sculptures that include landscape itself but the use of nature’s forces to realize continuously altered states of appearance. Like the material culture of nineteenth century rural cemeteries and public parks, these more recent works promise a continued dialogue about nature; its aesthetic value, its didactic function, its civic function, and the necessity for its preservation.
References
Sollins, Susan and Susan Dowling, Art:21— Art in the Twenty-First Century, Season One, PBS Home Video, 2003.
Tsai, Eugene. "Robert Smithson: Plotting a Line from Passaic, New Jersey to Amarillo, Texas." Robert Smithson, Ed. Eugene Tsai with Cornelia Butler, The Museum of Contemporary Art, LA, Berkeley, CA: University of California Press, 2004.
Thursday, December 20, 2007
The Creation Museum: Is It a Museum or a Church?
---In response to Leah Arroyo’s “Science on Faith at the Creation Museum, Museum News, Nov./Dec. 2007 and Edward Rothstein’s “Adam and Eve in the Land of the Dinosaurs,” New York Times, 24 May 2007.
Should institutions like the recently opened Creation Museum exist at all? Is it a museum or a church?
The debate over whether such a “museum” should exist reminds me of many debates from the past that continue to survive among some. One debate between Thomas Henry Huxley and Matthew Arnold in the nineteenth century was rooted in the idea of science becoming an integral part of public education. Arnold, a headmaster himself and noted poet, believed that life’s mysteries would be lost with the adoption of science to school curriculum. The knowledge that such mysteries about life existed were to him more valuable than nurturing the ability to explain all that lay before us through science.
It was the romantic William Wordsworth who authored that famous line: “We murder to dissect,” which, in essence, became a jeremiad for intellectuals like Arnold who believed that modern science would succeed at devaluing life itself through the act of “dissecting” it and thoroughly discovering how it worked. Huxley was one of the first evolutionists and his explanation of the beginning of life was a great challenge to Arnold and other like thinkers who believed the answers to these questions about man’s past had already been answered and that religious faith alone was its only test of accuracy. Contemporaries of Arnold like John Henry Cardinal Newman went so far as to belief that the fossils that evolutionists like Huxley held up as tangible evidence of their theories had been placed in the ground as a test of individual faith by God.
Here we are some one hundred and fifty years later with a Creation Museum in our American backyard, but interestingly enough the old argument that required us to choose between one explanation or another, as resulted from the earlier debates, has instead been given an irritating twist. It seems that faith alone is good enough for selling whatever version of the beginning that official creationist dogma deems the truth in Cincinnati’s suburbs. In fact, with the idea that dinosaurs once roamed the Earth more mainstream than ever, and seemingly unchallengeable to ever greater numbers, some creationists have found it convenient to adopt the prehistoric as part of their official genesis story regardless of the fact that these thunder lizards are never mentioned specifically in the Bible. Such textual ambiguities and lack of references in the Bible have served those wishing to push particular agendas in the past so why not now. Some have explained that God’s six day work week for the creation project may not have been 24 hour long days as we recognize them to be today. It may have been some longer period of time. If such accommodations are accepted, why not also explain that these days of undefined length may have begun with dinosaurs in a distant past and ended with more recent occurrences, like, for example, 20,000 years ago, when the beginning of man’s residency on Earth has often been marked.
Given the long establishment of secularized education and a mainstream acceptance of scientific authority, some creationists are using this new strategy of inclusion to win over converts. They mix and match science with their own interpretations of scripture-based “truth” about man’s beginning. What better means of delivery of their interpretation cum creationist view “adapted for modern readers” than through the apparatus of a modern-day museum.
I find this especially troubling because these creationists have turned the whole notion of the secularized museum on its ear. They have done what the most heinous of propagandists of the past have done and adopted new mediums to repackage their message for an audience susceptible to the lure of flash and spectacle as a reliable source of truth. Many may argue that this is no different than religious murals of the past but shouldn’t greater literacy in the modern era made this type of propaganda obsolete? The child-like vision of the beginning as realized three-dimensionally at the Creation Museum, may be an indicator of just who is being won over to this “truth” of the beginning.
In a recent article, one visitor is quoted as saying that” You can’t leave here without knowing the truth (Arroyo 2007).” Whose truth? In a nation that is often defined as evenly divided politically it is safe to bet that what is considered “truth” is, at least, bipolar not only politically but between those who give credence to evolutionary theory and those who don’t. Given this possibility, it is necessary that an equally strong presentation of the established opposing scientific view of “creation” be available to the public currently served by this new “museum.” The democratic conception of education itself necessitates that alternative truths be given a platform by which citizens can make informed decisions. With only a Creation Museum proximate to a portion of the population, this singular “truth” goes unchallenged.
The fact that promoters of “intelligent design” dismiss the possibility of offering “hypotheses subject to change in light of new data” ignores one of the basic premises of modern education, the adoption of the scientific method for processing knowledge itself, so, indeed, the Creation Museum is not a museum as the concept of museums has come to be popularly defined in this or many other countries. The “museum” serves as a respected institution for disseminating religious propaganda and dogma, and because of this it is more accurately a reconstituted church.
Because the Creation Museum makes use of the concept of “museum” as part of its identity, we should be alarmed. It is why it is the job of ICOM, AAM, and other museum organizations to educate people everywhere, including the Cincinnati area, that this is not a museum like other museums. After all, Ken Ham, AIG’s president and co-founder, admits himself that this museum is the work of “scriptwriters and designers.” Scriptwriters are responsible for fictions as well as “true stories,” but unlike them the curators of natural history museums are held up to a standard by which they act as facilitators of tangible evidence and more universally held theories rather than scripting the authorized and indisputable “truths” of a minority of church leaders.
This “museum” should receive nonprofit status as a church, and forgo the claim of being a museum and any of the funding that legitimate museums are deserving of. The success of this “museum” would undoubtedly initiate others to follow its model, but I have faith that such museums will only succeed at selling their ideas when they go unchallenged. Legitimate natural history museums offer what the Creation Museum doesn’t, and that is a necessary openness to new discoveries and a willingness to revise their theories rather than to promote unchallengeable absolutes.
Should institutions like the recently opened Creation Museum exist at all? Is it a museum or a church?
The debate over whether such a “museum” should exist reminds me of many debates from the past that continue to survive among some. One debate between Thomas Henry Huxley and Matthew Arnold in the nineteenth century was rooted in the idea of science becoming an integral part of public education. Arnold, a headmaster himself and noted poet, believed that life’s mysteries would be lost with the adoption of science to school curriculum. The knowledge that such mysteries about life existed were to him more valuable than nurturing the ability to explain all that lay before us through science.
It was the romantic William Wordsworth who authored that famous line: “We murder to dissect,” which, in essence, became a jeremiad for intellectuals like Arnold who believed that modern science would succeed at devaluing life itself through the act of “dissecting” it and thoroughly discovering how it worked. Huxley was one of the first evolutionists and his explanation of the beginning of life was a great challenge to Arnold and other like thinkers who believed the answers to these questions about man’s past had already been answered and that religious faith alone was its only test of accuracy. Contemporaries of Arnold like John Henry Cardinal Newman went so far as to belief that the fossils that evolutionists like Huxley held up as tangible evidence of their theories had been placed in the ground as a test of individual faith by God.
Here we are some one hundred and fifty years later with a Creation Museum in our American backyard, but interestingly enough the old argument that required us to choose between one explanation or another, as resulted from the earlier debates, has instead been given an irritating twist. It seems that faith alone is good enough for selling whatever version of the beginning that official creationist dogma deems the truth in Cincinnati’s suburbs. In fact, with the idea that dinosaurs once roamed the Earth more mainstream than ever, and seemingly unchallengeable to ever greater numbers, some creationists have found it convenient to adopt the prehistoric as part of their official genesis story regardless of the fact that these thunder lizards are never mentioned specifically in the Bible. Such textual ambiguities and lack of references in the Bible have served those wishing to push particular agendas in the past so why not now. Some have explained that God’s six day work week for the creation project may not have been 24 hour long days as we recognize them to be today. It may have been some longer period of time. If such accommodations are accepted, why not also explain that these days of undefined length may have begun with dinosaurs in a distant past and ended with more recent occurrences, like, for example, 20,000 years ago, when the beginning of man’s residency on Earth has often been marked.
Given the long establishment of secularized education and a mainstream acceptance of scientific authority, some creationists are using this new strategy of inclusion to win over converts. They mix and match science with their own interpretations of scripture-based “truth” about man’s beginning. What better means of delivery of their interpretation cum creationist view “adapted for modern readers” than through the apparatus of a modern-day museum.
I find this especially troubling because these creationists have turned the whole notion of the secularized museum on its ear. They have done what the most heinous of propagandists of the past have done and adopted new mediums to repackage their message for an audience susceptible to the lure of flash and spectacle as a reliable source of truth. Many may argue that this is no different than religious murals of the past but shouldn’t greater literacy in the modern era made this type of propaganda obsolete? The child-like vision of the beginning as realized three-dimensionally at the Creation Museum, may be an indicator of just who is being won over to this “truth” of the beginning.
In a recent article, one visitor is quoted as saying that” You can’t leave here without knowing the truth (Arroyo 2007).” Whose truth? In a nation that is often defined as evenly divided politically it is safe to bet that what is considered “truth” is, at least, bipolar not only politically but between those who give credence to evolutionary theory and those who don’t. Given this possibility, it is necessary that an equally strong presentation of the established opposing scientific view of “creation” be available to the public currently served by this new “museum.” The democratic conception of education itself necessitates that alternative truths be given a platform by which citizens can make informed decisions. With only a Creation Museum proximate to a portion of the population, this singular “truth” goes unchallenged.
The fact that promoters of “intelligent design” dismiss the possibility of offering “hypotheses subject to change in light of new data” ignores one of the basic premises of modern education, the adoption of the scientific method for processing knowledge itself, so, indeed, the Creation Museum is not a museum as the concept of museums has come to be popularly defined in this or many other countries. The “museum” serves as a respected institution for disseminating religious propaganda and dogma, and because of this it is more accurately a reconstituted church.
Because the Creation Museum makes use of the concept of “museum” as part of its identity, we should be alarmed. It is why it is the job of ICOM, AAM, and other museum organizations to educate people everywhere, including the Cincinnati area, that this is not a museum like other museums. After all, Ken Ham, AIG’s president and co-founder, admits himself that this museum is the work of “scriptwriters and designers.” Scriptwriters are responsible for fictions as well as “true stories,” but unlike them the curators of natural history museums are held up to a standard by which they act as facilitators of tangible evidence and more universally held theories rather than scripting the authorized and indisputable “truths” of a minority of church leaders.
This “museum” should receive nonprofit status as a church, and forgo the claim of being a museum and any of the funding that legitimate museums are deserving of. The success of this “museum” would undoubtedly initiate others to follow its model, but I have faith that such museums will only succeed at selling their ideas when they go unchallenged. Legitimate natural history museums offer what the Creation Museum doesn’t, and that is a necessary openness to new discoveries and a willingness to revise their theories rather than to promote unchallengeable absolutes.
Tuesday, November 20, 2007
More Thoughts About Being Child Friendly
My priorities for a museum visit have changed in recent years with the addition of children to my family, so I feel that having joined an important demographic for many museums, whose target audience is the family, I have become acutely aware of the particular needs of this audience and how they might best be served. Although many museums have redefined themselves as audience-centered in the past decade and have made efforts to become more "child friendly" with increased programming and development of interactive offerings, there are many that have more quickly adopted a rhetoric and put off physical accommodations for another day.
Often specific child age groups are ignored like pre-school children for those of school age; the Worcester Art Museum in Massachusetts is one that comes to mind. Although it has focused much on programming for school children, its physical plant has changed little in half a century. It hasn't struck on a way to engage children within the museum itself with its world-class collection of paintings, sculpture, and texture, although there have been some feeble attempts, or rather space and cues have been created for child audiences but without adequate staff, or even instructions for parent guided tours these remain silent and ineffective to the weekday visitor. A children's activity room lacks any written explanations for parent guides or links to the msueum's collections. There is a cool interactive screen that allows kids to draw with their finger on a screen and some other activities and second space for kids but, again, what about the collection itself; is that for adults alone? To be fair, this museum has some great print resources in their library, and space is devoted to children, but why would I come to the quietude of a museum with my children to sit in an equally restrictive library and look at books with them; I can do that at the public library with less need for restraint of my kids.
Other art museums, like Harvard’s Fogg Museum, which has seen little change architecturally in its interior in decades, perhaps longer, offers visitors with children little, for cramped elevators don’t accommodate some strollers, there are no bathroom changing stations, or official private nursing areas that have become par for the course for many museums that seemingly want greater attendance. But maybe I speak too soon, for the Fogg will undergo a major refitting soon. Until then, some of us who want museums to be an important part of their kids' childhood will have to keep searching for that perfect experience worth frequent and continued visits. The Peabody Essex is on that short list.
Often specific child age groups are ignored like pre-school children for those of school age; the Worcester Art Museum in Massachusetts is one that comes to mind. Although it has focused much on programming for school children, its physical plant has changed little in half a century. It hasn't struck on a way to engage children within the museum itself with its world-class collection of paintings, sculpture, and texture, although there have been some feeble attempts, or rather space and cues have been created for child audiences but without adequate staff, or even instructions for parent guided tours these remain silent and ineffective to the weekday visitor. A children's activity room lacks any written explanations for parent guides or links to the msueum's collections. There is a cool interactive screen that allows kids to draw with their finger on a screen and some other activities and second space for kids but, again, what about the collection itself; is that for adults alone? To be fair, this museum has some great print resources in their library, and space is devoted to children, but why would I come to the quietude of a museum with my children to sit in an equally restrictive library and look at books with them; I can do that at the public library with less need for restraint of my kids.
Other art museums, like Harvard’s Fogg Museum, which has seen little change architecturally in its interior in decades, perhaps longer, offers visitors with children little, for cramped elevators don’t accommodate some strollers, there are no bathroom changing stations, or official private nursing areas that have become par for the course for many museums that seemingly want greater attendance. But maybe I speak too soon, for the Fogg will undergo a major refitting soon. Until then, some of us who want museums to be an important part of their kids' childhood will have to keep searching for that perfect experience worth frequent and continued visits. The Peabody Essex is on that short list.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)